I was having this IM conversation a couple of weeks ago with a guy we’ll call Greg, because that is his name. It ended up being about whether or not certain books are hot, for example, “If you saw a girl reading a Homeric epic, would that be hot?” or “Pablo Neruda: hot or too obvious?” 1 That sort of thing. It started when Greg told me that he had fallen in love with a woman sitting nearby who was reading a book with such intense fascination that her mouth was hanging open. “Like a carp,” he said, and I never knew that carp-mouth was hot either, but as they say, to each his own. And then Greg fell out of love with the woman when he noticed that she was reading one of those books in the Left Behind series. Love, so fleeting. Ever was it so.
I can’t say that I’ve been thinking about the hotness of certain books since then, because if I were to say such a thing, I’d be lying. My brain is a busy place, and I think about a lot of things. But sometimes I would look at a book or think about book subject matter and evaluate hotness. (Like I was watching this thing on the History Channel about Lincoln — shut up, it was really interesting — and I thought “Are Lincoln biographies hot?” 2)
So anyway, since I am apparently never getting hired for anything ever 3, I have decided to turn my obvious brilliance toward altruism. I am hereby announcing myself as the world’s only living authority on the hotness of reading material. You want to know if what you’re reading is hot? (I mean, why else do you read?) I’m here to help.
To prove that I am actually an authority on the subject at hand, and not just some hack making things up for the purpose of amusing myself, though that is also a fair activity, I’m going to provide you with an arbitrary list of books and tell you whether or not they are hot. I figure that’s the way people become authorities: they declare themselves authorities and then they back themselves up by being authoritative. My goodness, can I ever be authoritative.
Let’s sally forth, like we’re in Don Quixote 4 or something:
Wuthering Heights – Emily Bronte
This is not hot. As I wrote here: 5 “…and Heathcliff? Well, yes, he was dark and brooding, but less in a hot way and more in a total asshole way. It’s like, listen dude, I understand that you’re dark and brooding and really busy brooding darkly about your dark pain, or something, but do you really have to be such a dick about it? For fuck’s sake, go have some ice cream and a nap, Sparky. Good lord.”
So, you know, obviously not hot.
Slowness – Milan Kundera
Hot. I didn’t think it was hot at first. In fact, I was kind of annoyed through about two-thirds of the book, but then I was like, “Oh snap!” The thing about Milan Kundera books is that they kind of seem to be entirely tangential and then everything falls into place and then it’s like “Oh, you sly bastard.” Plus, this book is about sex, so, you know. I think it’s probably especially hot if a guy is reading it, which I’m not going to explain, but just trust me.
French symbolist poetry
This depends. I mean, I was never hit on while I was reading A Season in Hell, for instance, so there’s that. I’m sure I was wearing black and everything. Probably even those reading glasses. Dammit, what do I have to do, anyway? Maybe it’s because I was reading it in Denny’s. What was I writing about? I don’t know. I haven’t had a Grand Slam in ages. 6
Ulysses – James Joyce
I grudgingly admit this is hot. But only if someone is actually reading it and not just pretending to read it because gosh, isn’t it impressive to sit somewhere holding Ulysses and looking smart? I’m not really sure how you’d tell the difference between someone who was actually reading and someone who was only pretending to read, however, because while you usually can tell if someone’s faking by whether or not that person ever turns any pages, with Ulysses sometimes it takes awhile to get through a page, because you have to read it, think “Wait, what?” and read it again, and then have your brain sidetrack you into some stupid tangent for several minutes, and then start over again. So it could conceivably take an hour to get to the next page in that book, is what I’m saying.
Books by Dan Brown
Only if the person is smirking. And possibly also cooking chili in his/her shoes. 7
Textbooks
No. Just no. 8
Novels by Chuck Palahniuk
My own opinion of Chuck Palahniuk novels is that they seem like a series of clever phrases that would work on bumper stickers and t-shirts strung together into book form, so I can’t say that I’m really a fan. I haven’t read everything he’s ever written, so maybe I’m not being entirely fair, as it’s really just one book (Diary) and the short story “Guts,” 9 which is apparently so shocking that people have been known to pass out at readings. It gives them the vapors, y’all! I don’t know. I suppose I’m just a jaded jerk, but I don’t shock easily, and instead of being surprised or disgusted, I would spot the places where I was supposed to be so surprised and disgusted and just feel irritated that the writing was trying to manipulate me. Badassery isn’t badass if it’s all “I’m so badass!” So anyway, I’m going to look beyond my own personal distaste and decide that this is only hot if you’re under the age of 25. After then and it’s like being that guy in his 30s who keeps showing up at high school parties, which is, you know, sad.
Things by Samuel Beckett
Only if it’s not Waiting for Godot, which, while very good, is kind of the obvious pick. 10 Anyway, reading Samuel Beckett is kind of hot, mainly because you just have to have a sense of the absurd.
Any book with a unicorn on the cover
Obviously not.
Jane Austen
I’m sure it’s perfectly obvious that I would say that reading Jane Austen is hot. But it’s also obvious that reading Jane Austen really is hot. Because come on, her books are the perfect combination of smart and funny, which is of course the deadliest combination of all time when it comes to sex appeal. 11
Anyway, there you go, with a few choices. Any questions? Go ahead and ask. I am an authority, after all.
________________________________________________________
1. Homeric epic: yes, hot. Pablo Neruda: depends entirely on context. Apparently reading Pablo Neruda in a coffee shop is obvious, but reading Pablo Neruda on the bus, say, is hot. Just so you know, the real estate rule of “Location, location, location,” holds true with the sex appeal of your reading choices as well.
2. Yes. This is not to say, however, that watching things about Lincoln on the History Channel is also hot, because what do I look like? The world’s only living authority on the hotness of television watching habits? Please.
3. I had a thought yesterday about this unemployment thing. I’m still looking, though I can’t say with any honesty that my heart is in it anymore. I mean, fuck, if you want to try out some reading material guaranteed to depress you, skip The Sorrows of Young Werther and just read through some classified ads and think about how you’d be all set if only you were qualified at everything you don’t know how to do, because it’s not like those typing test people are going to get back to you before you stick your head in an oven. I kid. Sort of. I’m not sticking my head in an oven, but looking for a job sucks so hard its eyes may pop out of its head.
4. You can be Sancho Panza, if you want. Also, Don Quixote? Not hot. Neither is singing songs from Man of La Mancha. It is amusing, however. Duuuulcineeeeaaaaaa.
5. As Part One of my own personal Brontepalooza, which concluded with Agnes Grey by Anne Bronte, which also isn’t hot, by the way. I did quite enjoy Jane Eyre, which is possibly hot. Mainly the thing I remember about this book is reading it for a class and everyone in the class kind of agreed that Jane was kind of a tease, which subsequently blew the professor’s mind. Here’s something on which we can certainly agree: being a tease is only hot in small doses.
6. NOT A EUPHEMISM.
7. John Travolta is dead. Long live John Travolta. (That’s just for Caryn.)
8. Obvious exception: physics.
9. The one about the boy in the pool? Is that what it’s called?
10. Endgame is better, anyhow.
11. You know, I remember reading a stereotype of single women once. There are the ones who end up alone except for about 47 cats, and then there are the ones who end up alone except for Jane Austen books. Jane Austen books won’t shed on you, which is definitely something to consider. If I’m going to end up a crazy old spinster, I will definitely be one of the Austen-reading variety, which is totally fine with me, because I’m looking forward to getting one of those wacky beaded glasses chains (it’s all in the details, people). And besides, I read in Time magazine recently that getting married increases your chances of being obese by something like 230%, so BACK OFF, GRANDMA. Ahem.